FREE worldwide shipping over $49 30-Day “Squishfaction” Guarantee Mix & match: 2 for $32.38 · 3 for $45.87 · 4 for $57.57
Butter Squishy — Random Color, Same Butter-Stick Style — Squeezy

Butter Squishy — Random Color & Print, Same Butter-Stick Style

SKU SQ-FS-CZ2570 · 1 / 2 / 3 pieces

Choose a 1, 2 or 3 Pack. Every piece has the same rectangular butter-stick style; color and wrapper print are selected at random, cannot be requested, and may repeat in multipacks.

✓Color and wrapper print selected at random — requests unavailable
✓Same rectangular butter-stick style and shape
✓Choose 1, 2 or 3 Pack; random selections may repeat
$14.99 $19.99 Save $5

Choose a pack size

squeezy+ Membership

Learn more about squeezy+
  • Extra 10% off every order
  • 2 free shipping orders every month
  • Cancel anytime
Questions about this product? Chat with Squeezy Support

● In stock — order today, ships by Nov 18

30-day return requests — mystery box exclusions apply

What's in the box?
1 / 2 / 3 pieces. SKU SQ-FS-CZ2570. Butter Squishy — Random Color & Print, Same Butter-Stick Style. Every squishy is checked before it ships.
Shipping & delivery
Worldwide delivery takes 8–14 business days from the order date. Shipping is $9.99, or FREE when your discounted merchandise total is $49 or more. Tracking is included.
Is it loud when it rises?
Completely silent — no squeaks, no whistles. Squish through meetings, libraries, and late-night deadlines.
Can it tear?
Slow-rising foam is made for squeezing, not sharp objects or pets. If your item arrives damaged or develops a normal-use defect within 30 days of delivery, contact us with your order number and a clear photo.
What if I don't love it?
Contact us within 30 days of delivery to request an eligible return or exchange. Opened mystery boxes and sets cannot be returned because of a change of mind or a preferred design. Damaged, incorrect or incomplete orders remain eligible for a replacement or refund. See our Refund & Return Policy; your statutory rights are unaffected.

Why hands keep coming back

This slow-rising butter squishy is a squeeze toy in a rectangular butter-stick shape.

The overall butter-stick style stays the same, while the color and printed wrapper are selected at random during fulfillment. Choose the 1, 2 or 3 Pack before adding it to your cart. Specific colors or prints cannot be requested, and a multipack may contain repeats.

Specs at a glance

ProductButter-stick squishy
Color and printSelected at random; cannot be requested
StyleSame rectangular butter-stick shape
Pack choices1 Pack, 2 Pack or 3 Pack
MultipacksRandom selections may repeat
ReturnSlow-rising

Why choose this one

Browse butter squishies, food squishies, squishy packs and sets or all squishies.

Specifications

Rebound
Slow-rising
SKU
SQ-FS-CZ2570
Pieces in this listing
1 / 2 / 3 pieces
Category
squishy toy

Worldwide Shipping

Worldwide delivery takes 8–14 business days. Shipping is $9.99, or FREE when your discounted merchandise total is $49 or more. Tracking is included.

GOT QUESTIONS? WE HAVE THE ANSWERS!

FAQ

Can I choose the color or print?

No. Both are selected at random when the order is fulfilled, so specific requests are unavailable.

Are the random options different shapes?

No. Every option keeps the same rectangular butter-stick style and shape; only the color and wrapper print may vary.

What do the 1, 2 and 3 Pack options mean?

They are the exact quantities in your order. Select one pack size before adding the product to your cart so the matching SKU is recorded.

Will a multipack contain different versions?

Not necessarily. Each piece is selected at random, so colors or prints may repeat in a two- or three-pack.

How does the squishy return after pressing?

It has a slow-rising return after it is pressed and released; no exact return time is promised.

SQUISHFACTION GUARANTEE

30-day return requests — See our return policy and mystery box exclusions.

Don't miss our other must-haves.

SLEEPY STAR IN A NIGHTCAP SQUISHY TOY photo
SLEEPY STAR IN A NIGHTCAP SQUISHY TOY $6.99
ROUNDED YELLOW STAR SQUISHY TOY photo
ROUNDED YELLOW STAR SQUISHY TOY $9.99
FIVE-PETAL FLOWER SQUISHY TOY - RANDOM COLOR photo
FIVE-PETAL FLOWER SQUISHY TOY - RANDOM COLOR $6.99
STAR WITH A WHISKERED FACE SQUISHY TOY photo
STAR WITH A WHISKERED FACE SQUISHY TOY $9.99
Butter Squishy — Random Color, Same Butter-Stick Style — Squeezy
Butter Squishy — Random Color & Print, Same Butter-Stick Style$14.99 $19.99Save $5
WhatsApp Support